What a health brand can say in an ad, and how to say it well

Health marketing tends to fail in one of two directions: copy so careful it says nothing, or copy that promises an outcome the brand can't prove. Sorting every claim before the brief goes out fixes both, and it takes one sheet.

Marina ComisiFounder, Paxton Studio

5 min read

Read ten health websites in a row and you'll see the pattern. "Personalized care." "Your health, simplified." "Expert support every step of the way." Most of it is true, none of it is checkable, and a buyer comparing three options can't tell them apart.

The usual explanation is regulation. In my reading, regulation explains less of it than people think. What usually happens is that nobody sorted the claims, so every sentence gets the same cautious treatment, including the ones the brand could state plainly. The direct answer: before anything is written, list every claim the brand wants to make and put each one in one of four bins. Two of those bins are where health brands win.

01Every claim goes in one of four bins

Take the brief, the current homepage and the last three ads. Pull out every sentence that promises something, and sort.

BinWhat goes in itWhat you do with it
1. Facts about youThings the company controls and can count: how fast you reply, how many clinics you vetted and on which criteria, what's included in the price, who answers the phoneSay them plainly, with the number. This is the richest bin and the most underused
2. Outcome claims you can proveA health benefit backed by evidence you hold on file, for the product itself and in the conditions you describeUse them in the exact scope of the evidence, with any limit stated where people will see it
3. True, but worded too wideA real benefit stated more broadly than the evidence, or a result that implies a guaranteeReword to the scope you can prove (next section)
4. Not yours to makeTreatment or cure claims you can't support, anything that could discourage someone from seeing a doctor, comparisons you can't documentRemove. No rewording rescues them

The US rules give a useful yardstick for bin 2. In its Health Products Compliance Guidance (December 2022), the FTC asks for "competent and reliable scientific evidence" behind health benefit claims, which generally means randomized, controlled human trials. It also says consumer surveys are anecdotal and can't carry a health claim, and that vague qualifiers such as "may" or "helps" don't fix an overreaching sentence. In the UK, Section 12 of the CAP Code sets the equivalent rules for health and beauty claims. Rules differ by country and by product, so the sheet is a first pass, and anything in bins 2 to 4 goes past your regulatory or medical reviewer.

In the EU, the frame depends on what you sell. For foods and supplements, Regulation 1924/2006 prohibits health claims unless they are authorized and on the EU list of permitted claims (Regulation 432/2012), with the exact wording and conditions of use. For medical devices, Article 7 of the Medical Device Regulation (2017/745) bans claims that attribute functions a device doesn't have, create a false impression about treatment or diagnosis, or fail to mention a likely risk. France adds its own layer: the ANSM forbids advertising reimbursed class IIb and III devices to the public, and requires prior authorization for a short list of devices, such as dermal fillers and self-tests. For a service brand (a clinic network, a booking platform, a care app), most of the copy lives in bin 1, which is exactly why it deserves the most attention.

The pattern I see most often in health copy is a thin bin 1. Brands spend their energy hedging outcome claims and forget to say the concrete things they control.

02Rewording keeps the selling power when it adds a fact

The instinct with a risky sentence is to soften it. "Improves sleep" becomes "may help support better sleep", which is weaker copy and, by the FTC's own reading, no safer. The better move is to narrow the claim to what you can show, then add a fact from bin 1 so the sentence still has something to hold on to.

A few illustrations, written for imaginary brands:

BeforeBinAfter
Say, a telehealth app: "Get better faster with our doctors."3"A licensed doctor reviews your request within [your measured median time], seven days a week."
Say, a fertility travel service: "The best clinics in Europe."3"We vetted [number] clinics against [number] criteria, and you see the score for each one."
Say, a hearing care network: "Hear like you used to."4"A hearing test with a licensed audiologist, then [your trial period] to try the devices at home."
Say, a supplement: "Clinically proven to boost energy."2 or 3If the trial tested the finished product: state the measured result and the population. If it tested one ingredient: say so, or drop it

The after column reads longer, and it does more work, because a buyer can check it. Every number in it is one the brand already owns: response times, criteria, trial periods, who does the work. Those are bin 1 facts, and they're the ones competitors can't copy by changing an adjective.

03Keep a claims sheet next to every brief

Once the sort is done, keep the result in one shared sheet, and send it with every brief to the agency, the freelancer and whoever writes the next landing page. One row per claim:

Claim, word for wordBinEvidence on file (link)Scope and limits to stateApproved by, dateWhere it's used
[the sentence][1 to 4][study, internal data, contract][population, conditions, what it doesn't cover][reviewer, date][pages, ads, emails]

Two rules make it work. A claim that isn't on the sheet doesn't go into copy, which ends the slow drift where each new ad stretches the last one a little further. And bin 1 gets refreshed every quarter, because the facts about you change: the response time improves, the number of vetted partners grows, the trial period gets longer. Those updates are free copy, already approved.

The sheet also shortens reviews. A medical or compliance reviewer who sees the evidence link next to each sentence can approve a page in one pass, instead of sending it back with questions.

04Start with bin 1

If you do one thing this week, open your homepage and count the sentences that contain a fact about you with a number in it. If the count is under three, write those sentences first, and the outcome claims will need less work to carry the page.

Marina Comisi

Founder of Paxton Studio. Strategy first, then the hands to make it happen, for startups and scale-ups.

Say hi. We reply like humans.

Tell us where you're stuck.

We'll tell you honestly if we can help.

Marina replies personally. No sales team, no obligation.

New · Playbook No. 02New playbookThe Anti-Robot Prompt PackDownload it →
Write me