Asics won Nike's worst billboard in 24 hours

In April 2026, Nike hung a sign in Boston that read "Runners welcome, walkers tolerated." Within a day it was gone. By race weekend, three rivals had turned it into their own advertising.

Marina ComisiFounder, Paxton Studio

6 min read

The week before the Boston Marathon, Nike's store on Newbury Street displayed a line meant to sound tough and knowing. It landed as a sneer at the thousands of people who walk part of the course, and at the disabled athletes who race it. Nike took it down, apologized that the message had "missed the mark", and replaced it with something gentler.

The interesting part of the story happened around it. Asics put up billboards reading "Runners. Walkers. All welcome." Altra ran "Run. Walk. Crawl." with a caption that did the rest of the work. Ecco handed out sneakers to walkers and set up cheering stations along the route. None of these brands had planned a Nike moment. All of them had something ready to say when it arrived.

Responding to a competitor's mistake is one of the cheapest forms of brand building there is, and one of the easiest to get wrong. I want to look at why these responses worked, where the same move backfires, and what a small team can prepare in advance.

01What Asics, Altra and Ecco actually put up

BrandResponseRegisterWhat it says about the brand
AsicsBillboards in Boston: "Runners. Walkers. All welcome."Calm statementWe were always for everyone. No mention of Nike needed
AltraAd led with "Run. Walk. Crawl." plus "Go where you're celebrated. Not where you're tolerated."Pointed winkWe know what just happened, and we're on your side
EccoBillboards reading "No run intended", 100 free pairs for walkers and spectators, cheering stations on the courseActionWe'll show up for you on race day

What strikes me is how little each of them actually said about Nike. Asics never named it. Altra's caption pointed at the situation without pointing at the company. Ecco turned a pun into a gesture that cost real money and produced real goodwill on the course.

All three also had a credible right to the message. Asics has spent decades as the shoe of everyday runners. Altra built its name on wide, roomy shoes for long distances. Ecco is a walking brand first. If a fashion label had put up the same billboard, it would have read as a stunt. From these three, it read as a reminder.

One more detail matters. Molly Seidel, an Olympic medalist, posted her own joke the same weekend: "Runners welcome. Walkers welcome. Power hikers tolerated." The runners themselves set the tone of the conversation, and the brands that sounded like the runners were welcome in it.

02Why it works: the rival writes the setup, you write the values

Positioning has always been relative. Al Ries and Jack Trout built a whole theory on it in the early 1980s: people file brands against each other, so the clearest way to say who you are is to stand next to someone who is already in the customer's mind. Avis did it with "We try harder" against Hertz. Challengers have done it ever since.

A competitor's public mistake is the rare moment when that contrast arrives for free. The leader has just told everyone, in its own words, what it values. Your job is to say, in yours, what you value instead, while the audience is still paying attention. The rival has written the setup. You only need the second line, and it lands because the audience already feels it.

This is also why the best responses stay positive. "All welcome" tells you something about Asics. Any line that named Nike would have pulled Asics into the fight and kept the spotlight on the rival. People share a response that says what they were thinking. They are much less keen to share one that sounds like a company enjoying a rival's bad day.

The economics are hard to beat. A handful of billboards in one city, bought or swapped quickly, rode on national coverage that Nike's mistake had already paid for. Ecco's version cost more because it included shoes and people on the course, but it bought something harder to get: a story about the brand doing something kind on a day everyone was watching.

03Where the same move backfires

The tactic looks easy, which is why it goes wrong so often. Three failure patterns come up again and again.

Mocking a choice you might make later

In 2016, Samsung ran ads poking fun at Apple for removing the headphone jack from the iPhone. Three years later, the Galaxy Note 10 shipped without one, and the old ads quietly disappeared. It happened again with chargers: Samsung teased Apple in 2020 for dropping the charger from the box, then did the same in 2021. If the rival's mistake is a business decision your own company might copy, your joke has an expiry date.

Laughing at the customers

Nike's sign failed because it mocked a group of people. A response that piles on, even in the rival's direction, risks doing the same thing. The safe target is always the situation or the rival's message, never the people who were offended or the people who still buy from the rival. Those people are your future customers.

Arriving late, or loud

A response that comes three days after the conversation has moved on reads as opportunism. One that is louder than the original mistake makes your brand the story. Asics bought a few billboards in one city. It didn't launch a national campaign about Nike.

Aldi is the useful counterexample, because it broke the "stay positive" rule and still won. When Marks & Spencer took legal action in April 2021 over Cuthbert, Aldi's caterpillar cake, Aldi went straight for the joke with #FreeCuthbert and a few cheeky posts. Then it relaunched Cuthbert with profits going to cancer charities that M&S also supports. The gesture is what made the cheekiness acceptable. The two retailers settled later that year.

04What to prepare before a rival slips

Speed is what turns a good idea into a win, and speed is mostly preparation. When the lights went out at the 2013 Super Bowl, Oreo's "You can still dunk in the dark" went up within minutes because the brand team and the people who could approve it were already in the same room. Most companies will never staff a war room. They can still do the thinking in advance.

Here is the short kit I'd put together for a challenger brand:

  1. Your values line, written down. One sentence on what you stand for that your main rival could get wrong. For Asics, something close to "running belongs to everyone". This becomes the second line of any future response.
  2. A list of the rival's likely stumbles. Price rises, product recalls, exclusionary messaging, a feature removed, an outage. For each, note whether your company might make the same move one day. If yes, cross it off.
  3. Two formats per stumble. One words-only response (a post, a billboard line, an email subject) and one gesture (a giveaway, a discount for people affected, a donation). Gestures travel further and age better.
  4. A named approver and a 24-hour rule. Who can say yes on a Saturday, and the cut-off after which you stay quiet because the moment has passed.
  5. A tone check. Read the draft aloud and ask whether a customer of the rival would smile or feel mocked. Only the first one ships.

None of this requires a big budget. It requires deciding, on a calm Tuesday, what you would say on a chaotic Sunday.

05The leader's bad day is a mirror

What Boston showed is that a competitor's mistake works like a mirror held up to the whole category. For a weekend, every running brand was being asked the same question: who is running for? Nike stumbled into a bad answer, and the brands that already had a good one got to be seen giving it.

You can't schedule your rival's next mistake. You can know, today, what you'll say when it happens.

Marina Comisi

Founder of Paxton Studio. Strategy first, then the hands to make it happen, for startups and scale-ups.

Want to write your values line before you need it? Say hi. We reply like humans.

Tell us where you're stuck.

We'll tell you honestly if we can help.

Marina replies personally. No sales team, no obligation.

New · Playbook No. 02New playbookThe Anti-Robot Prompt PackDownload it →
Write me